Dr. Joseph Maroon Co-authors Article on Concussion Danger of Slap Boxing

Sept 19, 2024 Neurosurgeons, Drs. Nitin Agarwal, Joseph Maroon and others at University of Pittsburgh’s School of Medicine, published a study that recorded and quantified signs of concussion in slap fighters.  This first-of-its-kind study identified the brutal dangers of slap fighting, including an approximately 80% risk of signs of concussion when participating in an event.

See in a Video Interview by CBS News done by Dr. Agarwal, describes the video finding for concussion they found when analyzing videos of slap fighters. The article appeared in JAMA Surgery on September 18, 2024, entitled, Video Analysis of Concussion Among Slap Fighting Athletes

A total of 78 fights were analyzed, comprising 333 slaps and 139 sequences among 56 contestants. Concussive signs were observed after 97 slaps (29.1%) and 72 sequences (51.8%). Of the 56 contestants, 44 (78.6%) had at least 1 concussive sign, and 20 instances of second impact (ie, a contestant showing a visible sign of concussion after having shown signs after a previous slap) were observed.

The article was also highlighted by Yahoo News on Sept 23, 2024, entitled, Slap fighting causes high risk of brain injury, doctors call for safeguards over alarming concussion rates. 

 

In the article Dr. Maroon is quoted:

Dr. Joseph Maroon, a co-author of the study and developer of concussion protocols for US sports leagues, stated: ““The worst possible thing to do in terms of possibly incurring brain damage is to return to a contact sport before the brain has completely recovered… the brain is more susceptible to damage with a lesser force.” He warned that the worst possible scenario is for an athlete to return to a contact sport before fully recovering from a concussion, increasing the risk of long-term brain damage.

Dr. Maroon is also quoted by the UK, DailyMail.com as follows:

Worse still, contestants are encouraged to keep playing, which is ‘the worst possible thing to do in terms of incurring brain damage,’ Dr Joseph Maroon, one of the Pittsburgh study authors, told BBC news. ‘The brain is more susceptible to damage with a lesser force [after concussion]. ‘So for an individual to have experienced concussion and then stand up and get hit again, it’s putting the athlete at increased risk.’

REF:
JAMA Surg. Published online September 18, 2024. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2024.2605